Shelter Island Fishing Report

April 10, 2017

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – During the Winter season the migratory fish have left the area and the variety of fish available in State waters are slim. Some anglers may still fish for Pollock and Cod, Atlantic. There are not a whole lot of boats still in the water so be sure to check with your local tackle shops to see who is still running trips. For inshore anglers, fishing from docks and piers around NY can yield some great catches of Herring. As long as the bays do not completely freeze over, you should be able to catch them using little more than a rainbow colored Sabiki rig. As we find varying weather conditions from day to day we encourage all anglers to stay safe and warm when fishing. This is a great opportunity to check out some of the current Pro Angler App features along with new additions coming soon. We look forward to bringing you more great Pro Reports when the bite fires back up.






Pro Angler Team

April 4, 2017

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – During the Winter season the migratory fish have left the area and the variety of fish available in State waters are slim. Some anglers may still fish for Pollock and Cod, Atlantic. There are not a whole lot of boats still in the water so be sure to check with your local tackle shops to see who is still running trips. For inshore anglers, fishing from docks and piers around NY can yield some great catches of Herring. As long as the bays do not completely freeze over, you should be able to catch them using little more than a rainbow colored Sabiki rig. As we find varying weather conditions from day to day we encourage all anglers to stay safe and warm when fishing. This is a great opportunity to check out some of the current Pro Angler App features along with new additions coming soon. We look forward to bringing you more great Pro Reports when the bite fires back up.






Pro Angler Team

March 29, 2017

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – During the Winter season the migratory fish have left the area and the variety of fish available in State waters are slim. Some anglers may still fish for Pollock and Cod, Atlantic. There are not a whole lot of boats still in the water so be sure to check with your local tackle shops to see who is still running trips. For inshore anglers, fishing from docks and piers around NY can yield some great catches of Herring. As long as the bays do not completely freeze over, you should be able to catch them using little more than a rainbow colored Sabiki rig. As we find varying weather conditions from day to day we encourage all anglers to stay safe and warm when fishing. This is a great opportunity to check out some of the current Pro Angler App features along with new additions coming soon. We look forward to bringing you more great Pro Reports when the bite fires back up.






Pro Angler Team

March 17, 2017

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – During the Winter season the migratory fish have left the area and the variety of fish available in State waters are slim. Some anglers may still fish for Pollock and Cod, Atlantic. There are not a whole lot of boats still in the water so be sure to check with your local tackle shops to see who is still running trips. For inshore anglers, fishing from docks and piers around NY can yield some great catches of Herring. As long as the bays do not completely freeze over, you should be able to catch them using little more than a rainbow colored Sabiki rig. As we find varying weather conditions from day to day we encourage all anglers to stay safe and warm when fishing. This is a great opportunity to check out some of the current Pro Angler App features along with new additions coming soon. We look forward to bringing you more great Pro Reports when the bite fires back up.






Pro Angler Team

March 10, 2017

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – During the Winter season the migratory fish have left the area and the variety of fish available in State waters are slim. Some anglers may still fish for Pollock and Cod, Atlantic. There are not a whole lot of boats still in the water so be sure to check with your local tackle shops to see who is still running trips. For inshore anglers, fishing from docks and piers around NY can yield some great catches of Herring. As long as the bays do not completely freeze over, you should be able to catch them using little more than a rainbow colored Sabiki rig. As we find varying weather conditions from day to day we encourage all anglers to stay safe and warm when fishing. This is a great opportunity to check out some of the current Pro Angler App features along with new additions coming soon. We look forward to bringing you more great Pro Reports when the bite fires back up.






Pro Angler Team

March 3, 2017

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – During the Winter season the migratory fish have left the area and the variety of fish available in State waters are slim. Some anglers may still fish for Pollock and Cod, Atlantic. There are not a whole lot of boats still in the water so be sure to check with your local tackle shops to see who is still running trips. For inshore anglers, fishing from docks and piers around NY can yield some great catches of Herring. As long as the bays do not completely freeze over, you should be able to catch them using little more than a rainbow colored Sabiki rig. As we find varying weather conditions from day to day we encourage all anglers to stay safe and warm when fishing. This is a great opportunity to check out some of the current Pro Angler App features along with new additions coming soon. We look forward to bringing you more great Pro Reports when the bite fires back up.






Pro Angler Team

February 15, 2017

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – During the Winter season the migratory fish have left the area and the variety of fish available in State waters are slim. Some anglers may still fish for Pollock and Cod, Atlantic. There are not a whole lot of boats still in the water so be sure to check with your local tackle shops to see who is still running trips. For inshore anglers, fishing from docks and piers around NY can yield some great catches of Herring. As long as the bays do not completely freeze over, you should be able to catch them using little more than a rainbow colored Sabiki rig. As we find varying weather conditions from day to day we encourage all anglers to stay safe and warm when fishing. This is a great opportunity to check out some of the current Pro Angler App features along with new additions coming soon. We look forward to bringing you more great Pro Reports when the bite fires back up.






Pro Angler Team

February 9, 2017

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – During the Winter season the migratory fish have left the area and the variety of fish available in State waters are slim. Some anglers may still fish for Pollock and Cod, Atlantic. There are not a whole lot of boats still in the water so be sure to check with your local tackle shops to see who is still running trips. For inshore anglers, fishing from docks and piers around NY can yield some great catches of Herring. As long as the bays do not completely freeze over, you should be able to catch them using little more than a rainbow colored Sabiki rig. As we find varying weather conditions from day to day we encourage all anglers to stay safe and warm when fishing. This is a great opportunity to check out some of the current Pro Angler App features along with new additions coming soon. We look forward to bringing you more great Pro Reports when the bite fires back up.






Pro Angler Team

February 3, 2017

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – During the Winter season the migratory fish have left the area and the variety of fish available in State waters are slim. Some anglers may still fish for Pollock and Cod, Atlantic. There are not a whole lot of boats still in the water so be sure to check with your local tackle shops to see who is still running trips. For inshore anglers, fishing from docks and piers around NY can yield some great catches of Herring. As long as the bays do not completely freeze over, you should be able to catch them using little more than a rainbow colored Sabiki rig. As we find varying weather conditions from day to day we encourage all anglers to stay safe and warm when fishing. This is a great opportunity to check out some of the current Pro Angler App features along with new additions coming soon. We look forward to bringing you more great Pro Reports when the bite fires back up.






Pro Angler Team

January 27, 2017

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – During the Winter season the migratory fish have left the area and the variety of fish available in State waters are slim. Some anglers may still fish for Pollock and Cod, Atlantic. There are not a whole lot of boats still in the water so be sure to check with your local tackle shops to see who is still running trips. For inshore anglers, fishing from docks and piers around NY can yield some great catches of Herring. As long as the bays do not completely freeze over, you should be able to catch them using little more than a rainbow colored Sabiki rig. As we find varying weather conditions from day to day we encourage all anglers to stay safe and warm when fishing. This is a great opportunity to check out some of the current Pro Angler App features along with new additions coming soon. We look forward to bringing you more great Pro Reports when the bite fires back up.






Pro Angler Team

January 20, 2017

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – During the Winter season the migratory fish have left the area and the variety of fish available in State waters are slim. Some anglers may still fish for Pollock and Cod, Atlantic. There are not a whole lot of boats still in the water so be sure to check with your local tackle shops to see who is still running trips. For inshore anglers, fishing from docks and piers around NY can yield some great catches of Herring. As long as the bays do not completely freeze over, you should be able to catch them using little more than a rainbow colored Sabiki rig. As we find varying weather conditions from day to day we encourage all anglers to stay safe and warm when fishing. This is a great opportunity to check out some of the current Pro Angler App features along with new additions coming soon. We look forward to bringing you more great Pro Reports when the bite fires back up.






Pro Angler Team

January 11, 2017

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Hey anglers! In order to bring you valuable, up to date content such as regulations, GPS Hotspots, and BRAND NEW features the Pro Angler App Pro Reports will be returning the week of January 16, 2017. Please feel free to take a look at last week’s reports for an idea of what’s biting or give your favorite local bait shop a shout! The Pro Angler App looks forward to bringing you lots of exciting changes as we kick off 2017!






Pro Angler Team

January 6, 2017

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – During the Winter season the migratory fish have left the area and the variety of fish available in State waters are slim. Some anglers are still targeting the Cod (Cod, Atlantic) that are typically biting off of Montauk. Seasonal Pollock can also be found. Every now and then there are Herring to be found in the bays inshore. As we find varying weather conditions from day to day we encourage all anglers to stay safe and warm when fishing. This is a great opportunity to check out some of the current Pro Angler App features along with new additions coming soon! We look forward to bringing you more great Pro Reports when the bite fires back up! PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!






Pro Angler Team

December 30, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Herring can almost always be caught inshore durng the winter. They hold up around docks and structures for the most part. You can generally Sabiki them up fairly easily. Surf fishing is closing down at this point. Few Stripers (Bass, Striped) remain in the area. Anglers are heading towards Block Island to fish them. It is quite cold so many anglers done for the season and staying warm inside.






Tight Lines Tackle Inc
631-725-0740
www.tightlinestackleinc.com

December 23, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – The surf fishing season has come to a close for us. The fish have migrated out of the area. Bass (Bass, Striped) and Bluefish were phenomenal along with the False Albacore (Bonito, Little Tunny) bite this year. Cod fish (Cod, Atlantic), Blackfish (Tautog) and Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black) can still be found on the bottom. Cod are up to 10 lbs. Head East towards Block Island for the best bite. Tautog and Sea Bass are a bit scattered. There are not a lot of anglers heading out for them. It is quite cold so many anglers done for the season and staying warm inside. MERRY CHRISTMAS & HAPPY HOLIDAYS FROM THE PRO ANGLER TEAM!



BAIT REPORT – Herring can still be caught towards Montauk and to the East. Centerport Long Island is holding Herring around the Dam.


Tight Lines Tackle Inc
631-725-0740
www.tightlinestackleinc.com

December 13, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – The Scallop season is winding down at this point along with a lot of saltwater fishing. Some anglers are heading towards Montauk where there are still some small Stripers (Bass, Striped) on the beach. They are still being caught outside on the troll and using Diamond Jigs. Most are shorts as well. The bigger fish have moved off and we are mostly seeing the small sizes. Blackfish (Tautog) are on the wrecks a bit farther out. Green Crabs are best when they are available. Clams are a great alternative and may catch Cod (Cod, Atlantic) and Ling (Hake) incidentally.






Jack’s True Value Hardware & Marine
631-749-0114

December 7, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Most anglers are scalloping at this point. Weakfish are in the gut so you’ll need a boat. Bottom rigs are all you’ll need to fish for them. Clams or Squid are good baits to use. Just be sure not to set the hook too hard. Stripers (Bass, Striped) have headed South to deeper water. Blackfish (Tautog) are open for a few more days (December 15) and are biting around Montauk. They are the main target of most anglers.



BAIT REPORT – Bunker (Menhaden) seem to have moved out. There may be some Herring (Threadfin) out there under the birds in the harbor.


Jack’s True Value Hardware & Marine
631-749-0114

December 7, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Most anglers are scalloping at this point. Weakfish are in the gut so you’ll need a boat. Bottom rigs are all you’ll need to fish for them. Clams or Squid are good baits to use. Just be sure not to set the hook too hard. Stripers (Bass, Striped) have headed South to deeper water. Blackfish (Tautog) are open for a few more days (December 15) and are biting around Montauk. They are the main target of most anglers.



BAIT REPORT – Bunker (Menhaden) seem to have moved out. There may be some Herring (Threadfin) out there under the birds in the harbor.


Jack’s True Value Hardware & Marine
631-749-0114

December 7, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Most anglers are scalloping at this point. Weakfish are in the gut so you’ll need a boat. Bottom rigs are all you’ll need to fish for them. Clams or Squid are good baits to use. Just be sure not to set the hook too hard. Stripers (Bass, Striped) have headed South to deeper water. Blackfish (Tautog) are open for a few more days (December 15) and are biting around Montauk. They are the main target of most anglers.



BAIT REPORT – Bunker (Menhaden) seem to have moved out. There may be some Herring (Threadfin) out there under the birds in the harbor.


Jack’s True Value Hardware & Marine
631-749-0114

December 7, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Most anglers are scalloping at this point. Weakfish are in the gut so you’ll need a boat. Bottom rigs are all you’ll need to fish for them. Clams or Squid are good baits to use. Just be sure not to set the hook too hard. Stripers (Bass, Striped) have headed South to deeper water. Blackfish (Tautog) are open for a few more days (December 15) and are biting around Montauk. They are the main target of most anglers.



BAIT REPORT – Bunker (Menhaden) seem to have moved out. There may be some Herring (Threadfin) out there under the birds in the harbor.


Jack’s True Value Hardware & Marine
631-749-0114

November 30, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Peconic bay is pretty well done for the year. The beachfront is holding schoolie Bass taking curly tails or swimming plugs. Moving tide is best to fish from Riverhead to Orient. Plum Island is holding Blackfish (Tautog) on the North side and around Rocky Point. There are still some small schools of Albies (Bonito, Little Tunny) off Truman Beach and the Point.






Jamesport Bait & Tackle
631-298-5450

November 21, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – There isn’t much going on this week. There are some fish swimming the ocean but the wind has made getting on the water difficult. Prior to this system anglers were finding Bluefish off the beach up to 20 lbs taking artificials. The ocean had occasional Bass (Bass, Striped) here and there but they are mostly small. We expect most of the Bass have moved South.






Warren’s Tackle Center
631-722-4898

November 16, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Loads of Stripers are all over the bays and the back bays for anglers casting rubber Shad and Bucktails, Diamond Jigs or Popping Plugs. Plenty of fish are swimming the Smith Point Bridge. The inshore bays are loaded with Bunker and other bait. Stripers are there and feeding on them. Along the beach has had a similar bite. There is a lot of Bunker and bait moving down the surf and Bass are hitting the bait schools. When the subtle wind pushes the bait to the beach the fishing is great. A bit of surf movement will always bring them in. There is a bit of Tautog (Blackfish) being caught. A lot are shorts with a few keepers in the mix. Wreck fishing is picking up with decent sized Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black) and a few keeper Tautog. The bite is hit or miss in terms of when to get out on the water. Changing tides are your best bet. Clams and Squid are more productive for the Sea Bass and Porgy (Scup). Green Crabs are great for the Tautog. Stripers are biting towards Gardiners islands taking three way rigs with bucktails or drifting live Eels in 40-50 ft of water. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!

OFFSHORE – The Tuna (Tuna, Bluefin) bite has been slow. Hudson Canyon and Veatch Canyon are your best places to search for them. Swordfishing (Billfish – Swordfish) has been pretty steady. They are in 300-600 ft of water. Whole Squid is best to catch them at night with a glow stick and a rattle. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!

BAIT REPORT – Bunker (Menhaden) are in the bays and the beach.


Dick’s Bait & Tackle
631-281-9070

November 8, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – There are a lot of Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black) in the Sound still. They are in about 80 ft of water. Blackfish (Tautog) are in the Sound as well but the farther East you go the better they are. Bluefish and Bass (Bass, Striped) are swimming the surf with a few leftover Albies (Bonito, Little Tunny). Find the right tide to fish them. There isn’t much coming out of the bay this week. The North side of Plum Island has a lot of Stripers.

OFFSHORE – Tuna (Tuna, Bigeye) up to 130lbs are biting well. A few Yellowfin (Tuna, Yellowfin) are mixed in. Bluefin (Tuna, Bluefin) are on their way. The Bluefin we’ve seen so far are small and can be caught on the troll on the way out or back. Most fish are 100 miles or more offshore. Overnight we are seeing small Swords (Billfish – Swordfish). There’s some decent fish to be caught at the Hudson Canyon. It’s doing much better than the Atlantic Canyon. Island Bait & Tackle 718-885-2153 https://proangler.us/capt/IslandBaitTackleBrooklyn.jpg




Jamesport Bait & Tackle
631-298-5450

November 1, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – The surf fishing is decent on the Sound and Southeast. Albacore (Bonito, Little Tunny) are being caught along with Bass (Bass, Striped) and Bluefish. Bucktails and Polaris Poppers are good for the Bass. Occasionally a Diamond jig with a green tube on the end is productive. The wind has kept a lot of anglers inside. On the oceanside we are seeing a hit and miss bite. Blackfish (Tautog) are scattered. Most are small. Search the rock piles to find them.






Warren’s Tackle Center
631-722-4898

October 25, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Bluefish and Bass (Bass, Striped) are chasing Bunker around the island. They are literally making waves as they push the bait. The water is still warm so there are quite a few short Bass. The run should move a little more in the Shelter Island area. If the bait slows down they will be nice and hungry during their migration. Big Bluefish up to 12 lbs are not uncommon. It has been a little tough getting them to bite with all of the bait in the water. Anglers are live lining Bunker to hook them. The wind has kept anglers inside as they are not heading far offshore. There are still some anglers targeting Porgy (Scup) however this has been a scattered bite. Scallops are scattered. There have been some reports of them inside however they are also reported from down in the Peconics.



BAIT REPORT – There is an unbelievable amount of Bunker (Menhaden) swimming this week. They are all over the island and can be snagged or netted.


Jack’s True Value Hdw & Marine
631-749-0114

October 19, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Off the beaches, anglers are doing well with Bass (Bass, Striped), Bluefish and False Albacore (Bonito, Little Tunny) that are still hanging around. Quality Weakfish are still biting into this week as well. Porgy (Scup) and Blackfish (Tautog) are up around the North side of Plum Island. Towards Pigeon Rip we are seeing great Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black). Bluefish and Stripers are mixed in.






Jamesport Bait & Tackle
631-298-5450

October 12, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – In the bay we are seeing Bluefish to 4 lbs with a few bigger fish up to 10 lbs mixed in. There is a mixed bag of small Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black), Porgy (Scup) and Blowfish (Puffer, Smooth). Small Stripers (Bass, Striped) are turning up around the Smith Point Bridge area and Buoy 14 and 15 in the bay. There are some nice sizes in the inlet on live Eels and live bait. Anglers are also drifting Clams. Blackfish (Tautog) is doing well along the West Jetty of the inlet as well as all jetties on the inlets on the South shore including reefs and structure. They are mixed with Sea Bass and Porgy. Surf casting is picking up on the sand beaches along the South shore for Stripers and Bluefish. Popping Plugs or Diamond Jigs with green/white tails are best. Fresh Clams are working as well. Things are heating up for the fall run as fish invade the beach and inlet. It’s a lot of surf casting, drifting Eels and drifting Clams in the inlet. Green Crabs are best for the Blackfin. It’s been rough for anglers getting offshore due to the wind and heavy seas from the storm. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!






Dick’s Bait & Tackle
631-281-9070

October 4, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Things are slow this week. A few Porgy (Scup) are still around. Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black) are sporadic. When you find them they are really good in deep water. Bluefish are here and there. Bass (Bass, Striped) are pretty well the same.






Warren’s Tackle Center
631-722-4898

September 27, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – The Sound is holding Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black) and a few scattered Porgy (Scup). Bluefish are mixed in there also. They are also on the point with Sea Bass as well. Stripers (Bass, Striped) are slow in this part of the sound. In the Bay near Robin’s Island we are seeing Blowfish (Puffer, Smooth), Kingfish (Kingfish, Southern), and Porgy by Buoy 22. Buoy 17 is holding Blowfish and Bluefish on the last few hours of the incoming tide. Weakfish are in Noyack Bay to Paradise Point. Sea Bass are small, if you can get out on the North side of Plum Island on Pigeon Rip during a slack tide you will find some good sizes.






Jamesport Bait & Tackle
631-298-5450

September 20, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Fluke [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] is closed this week but fishing was good. There is a lot of mixed fish in the bay. Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black), Blowfish (Puffer, Smooth), small Stripers, Snappers, and Weakfish are biting. Bigger Stripers (Bass, Striped) up to 20 lbs are in the inlet. There are also Bluefish in the 10 lb or more range. They are drifting Clams or live Eels and casting Peanut Bunker for the Stripers. Even Porgy (Scup) are productive. The incoming tide has been best. All in all, the Striper fishing is decent. Gardiners is producing Striped Bass up to 40 lbs trolling parachutes or trolling bucktails and umbrella rigs. Eels are working out here as well. Look for them in 40-60ft of water. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!

OFFSHORE – There are still some Sharks to be caught although they are slowing down. Yellowfin and Bluefin (Tuna, Yellowfin & Tuna, Bluefin) are biting around 30 miles. The recent storm has pushed them out. Anglers are trolling until they find the bite then switch to chunking or jigging. The night bite is best on the chunk. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!




Dick’s Bait & Tackle
631-281-9070

September 20, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Fluke [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] is closed this week but fishing was good. There is a lot of mixed fish in the bay. Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black), Blowfish (Puffer, Smooth), small Stripers, Snappers, and Weakfish are biting. Bigger Stripers (Bass, Striped) up to 20 lbs are in the inlet. There are also Bluefish in the 10 lb or more range. They are drifting Clams or live Eels and casting Peanut Bunker for the Stripers. Even Porgy (Scup) are productive. The incoming tide has been best. All in all, the Striper fishing is decent. Gardiners is producing Striped Bass up to 40 lbs trolling parachutes or trolling bucktails and umbrella rigs. Eels are working out here as well. Look for them in 40-60ft of water. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!

OFFSHORE – There are still some Sharks to be caught although they are slowing down. Yellowfin and Bluefin (Tuna, Yellowfin & Tuna, Bluefin) are biting around 30 miles. The recent storm has pushed them out. Anglers are trolling until they find the bite then switch to chunking or jigging. The night bite is best on the chunk. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!




Dick’s Bait & Tackle
631-281-9070

September 14, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Porgy (Scup) and Snapper (Bluefish) are the main bites inshore this week. They are swimming the Peconics. Montauk has been red hot for a lot of different fish from Fluke [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] to Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black) to Stripers (Bass, Striped) so a lot of anglers are heading to this area.






Warren’s Tackle Center
631-722-4898

September 7, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – The weather is just starting to turn back to more ideal conditions recently. The fishing has been thrown off a bit and a lot of anglers have opted to stay inside.There was some consistent Fluke [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] biting before the storm hit. We expect a great Striper (Bass, Striped) bite very soon as Montauk has been productive in deeper water and in the back. The South shore should heat up quickly. Clams have worked well as bait, especially throughout the inlet. The big fish should be here in the next few weeks. Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black) and Porgy (Scup) were on the inshore reefs. Most of the fish are shorts. Blowfish (Puffer, Smooth) and Snappers (Bluefish) can be found in the bay. Once things really settle down we will be able to see how the fish were affected by the storm. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!

OFFSHORE – Prior to the storm Yellowfin and Bluefin (Tuna, Yellowfin & Tuna, Bluefin) were as close as 15 miles. Anglers were trolling or chunking Butterfish or Bunker to hook them. A few White Marlin (Billfish – Marlin, White) and Mahi (Dolphin) were also caught on the troll. You can also toss baits around debris for Mahi. Shark (Shark, Shortfin Mako) fishing is slow as most anglers are targeting the Tuna. The Canyons were a bit slow as the best bites are coming from inside 50 miles. In the 100 square, there are Tuna up to 100 lbs on the chunk or jigs. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!

BAIT REPORT – Crabbing has been excellent this year.


Dick’s Bait & Tackle
631-281-9070

August 30, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Striped Bass (Bass, Striped) remain great out in Montauk. Live Spot are working well to hook them. The day bite is best. Live Porgy or Bunker will work as well. Trolling wire line outfits is a great alternative with a variety of different lures. In the evening live Eels are best. Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black), Fluke [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] and Cod (Cod, Atlantic) are East of Montauk in deeper water on structure. Bluefish are on Plum Gut and in the Race. Striped Bass are a little scarce here. The Peconics are having a hard time with the hot water and Red Tide. The Weakfish are still pretty good, although the numbers are dropping a bit. Kingfish (Kingfish, Northern) and Blowfish (Puffer, Smooth) have also been caught. Snapper fishing is not as good as it should be at this time of year.



BAIT REPORT – Crabbing in the Peconics is fantastic.


Tight Lines Tackle Inc
631-725-0740
www.tightlinestackleinc.com

August 23, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – All good Fluking [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] is in full swing around the South shore. Lots of keepers and limits are turning up. Fish to 12 lbs have been caught on Killies, Spearing, Squid and Gulp on the back of White or Chartreuse Bucktails. Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black) and Porgy (Scup) are on the reef but most are short as they’ve been picked out. The deeper wrecks are holding bigger fish. You’ll have to move past 80 ft to 120 ft or better. Bassing (Bass, Striped) is hot at Montauk but it slows down the farther West you head. There are some Albacore (Bonito, Little Tunny) scooting around and they are really close to the beach and all the way out to 30 miles. They are feeding on small bait. The Fluke are hot in the Peconics and out towards Gardiners along with Striped Bass. The North shore is good for Porgy. Snappers (Small Bluefish) are doing fine as well. Spearing or Silversides will hook them. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!

OFFSHORE – A lot of Mahi (Dolphin), Bluefin and Yellowfin (Tuna, Bluefin & Tuna, Yellowfin) are in close. The Tuna can be trolled 10-15 miles out. Ballyhoo, Cedar Plugs, Green Machines and Daisy Chains are all working.They are 25-40 lbs. Farther out towards the Canyons has been quiet. Mahi are loving Bunker pods in the ocean. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!

BAIT REPORT – Bunker (Menhaden) are in the bays and ocean to 120 ft. Crabbing is excellent on the South shore this week.


Dick’s Bait & Tackle
631-281-9070

August 17, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – The fish have moved out of the bays a bit to search for cooler water. The Weakfish bite has been fantastic this year. Buoy 16 area and down by Jessop’s has been holding fish. Even Smith’s Cove has been hot. Porgy (Scup) are everywhere and they are big. Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black) are doing extremely well out of Gardiners around the flats. It has not been a great Fluke [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] season but there are some big sizes between Gardiners and Montauk. The Bass (Bass, Striped) are hitting off Little Gull and there are a fair amount of keepers. some 48’s are coming right off the beach on poppers on the early morning bite. With the warm water a lot of fish have moved out. Snapper (Bluefish) are here and the Snapper derby is coming up Labor Day weekend. Cocktail Blues are in the harbor and have been for a while. They are around 2 lbs. Blowfish (Puffer, Smooth) can be netted. This is a good sign for a good Blowfish season if the Bass don’t eat them up. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!

OFFSHORE – Things are starting to pick up in the Canyons. Around the Hudson there has been some Bigeye and Yellowfin (Tuna, Bigeye & Tuna, Yellowfin) caught. There has been action to the East as well. Anglers are mostly catching them on the troll. Wahoo are swimming from 30-40 fathoms. Mahi (Dolphin) are holding up on debris. The Bluefin (Tuna, Bluefin) have moved to the east off of Montauk and the dump.

BAIT REPORT – Huge Crabs are around. Bunker (Menhaden) are swimming. They are small but they are here. They will get bigger as the season progresses.


Jacks True Value Hdw & Marine
631-749-0114

August 9, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – There are a lot of small Snapper and cocktail Bluefish at the local beaches, Crab Meadow and Sunken Meadow. Lots of Porgy (Scup) are around the docks and beaches as well. Stripers (Bass, Striped) are a bit slow from shore however anglers are catching them on the deep drop offs around structure on chunks. Big Bluefish are on Bunker pods in the 10-15 lb class. Porgy are all over the buoys with some Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black) mixed in. Fluking [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] has slowed down a bit but you can still pick a few keepers off deeper drop offs in the triangle. Cow Harbor Bait & Tackle is a weigh station for the upcoming Bluefish tournament! PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!






Dick’s Bait & Tackle
631-281-9070

August 2, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Fluke [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] are in Shinnecock bay. The Sea Bass are a bit small. A lot of Mackerel have shown up. A lot of Weakfish are in Rose’s Grove and Peconic bay. Squid on a high-low rig has fished best during the outgoing tide. Bluefish are on the last two hours of the flood tide using Diamond Jigs. Try fishing buoy 17 hard. Porgy (Scup) are scattered throughout the bay on Robin’s Island and the MIddle Grounds. Blowfish (Puffer, Smooth) have been on the North and South of Robin’s Island. In the Sound there are are Porgy, Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black), and Bass (Bass, Striped) at night using Eels. The Bass in the gut are hit and miss from day to day. They’ve been a little tough to predict so you just have to be in the right place at the right time. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!



BAIT REPORT – Mackerel are swimming this week. There are tons of Bunker (Menhaden) as well.


Jamesport Bait & Tackle
631-298-5450

July 26, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Fluke [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] are in the Shinnecock bay. Porgy (Scup) are in Peconic Bay. By the bridge we are seeing Bass (Bass, Striped) on Clam Chum. Over by the inlet small Bluefish have shown up. Triggerfish (Triggerfish, Gray) have begun to swim the canal. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!

OFFSHORE – Bluefin (Tuna, Bluefin) are swimming offshore and can be caught on Green Machines or Ballyhoo. Some Sharks (Shark, Thresher & Shark, Shortfin Mako) are hanging around too. They are chasing the Mackerel that have shown up in roughly 100 ft of water. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!

BAIT REPORT – Bunker (Menhaden) are everywhere. Squid are 3 miles out in big concentrations.


East End Bait & Tackle
631-728-1744
scott@eastendbaitandtackle.com

July 22, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – The Peconics are getting warmer and warmer. Around Jessop’s there are a lot of Bluefish on the incoming tide that are small but plentiful. They are up to 4 lbs. Loads of Weakfish are in the Peconics around Rose’s Grove. They are producing great numbers around 28. Porgy (Scup) are all through the Peconics and into Sag Harbor. They are on the smaller size. There is some local Fluke [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)]. The bite in Montauk with the Stripers (Bass, Striped) is incredible. They are up to 50 lbs biting Eels from sunset into darkness. Fluke and Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black) are to the East. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!

OFFSHORE – The bite is great this week. We have found some Bigeyes (Tuna, Bigeye), Yellowfin (Tuna, Yellowfin) and a hundred pound Wahoo. The bite is significant.




Tight Lines Tackle Inc
631-725-0740
www.tightlinestackleinc.com

July 15, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Peconic bay has had some Weakfish. Weakfish are scattered all over the place. Use a Hi-Lo Rig as Porgy (Scup) are still around too. They are drifting to find them between the point and the island. Cocktail Bluefish are showing up on Diamond Jigs during outgoing tide. Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black) have moved out to deeper water. Off Gardiners we are seeing Fluke [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] and Sea Bass. The Sound has Sea Bass, Porgy, Fluke and big Bluefish. Montauk had a good run of Stripers (Bass, Striped) but they seem to have moved out. PRO ANGLER APP USERS – Tap a fish below the report for more angling tips and tricks!






Jamesport Bait & Tackle
631-298-5450

July 6, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Things are a bit quiet this week. Porgy (Scup) are still in the bay and the Sound this week. There are Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black) mixed in as well from 45-50 ft of water around rocky areas. Most fish are in the sound off the motel in Mattituck or the Point. There are some small Bluefish around as well as the occasional Weakfish. They can be caught from shore.






Warren’s Tackle Center
631-722-4898

June 28, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – It’s a challenging time of year for anglers. The water temperature is rising and the bigger fish are moving North or East. We have seen a great run of good fish but right now the best place to find a good Striper (Bass, Striped) is the Plum Gut or the race which is just East of Plum Island. Most are small and not keepers. Anglers are deep jigging them with a heavy weight. Pork Rind Substitutes are working well too. Bluefish are persisting throughout the season. They are holding up in the ferry slips. They are over 20 lbs, which is uncommon. Most Bluefish in the Peconics are smaller, around 2-8 lbs. A lot of Porgy, Weakfish and Bluefish are hot. Tight Lines Tackle Inc is closed on Wednesdays but open every other day! Stop in for some great products!

OFFSHORE – Sea Bass (Sea Bass, Black) are now open. Most are not keepers but if you put some time in you may find a few. The Fluking [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] is not what we have hoped. The better fish are in the ocean from 60-90 ft.




Tight Lines Tackle Inc
631-725-0740
www.tightlinestackleinc.com

June 22, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Anglers are searching for Fluke [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] this week. They have been slow so far. There are reports from Peconic Bay and Shinnecock Bay. They are a bit scattered though and there are no big concentrations. Buoy 17 in the Jessop’s Bay will produce Fluke and you may pick up some Striped Bass from the bottom. Porgy (Scup) are still in the middle grounds and buoy 6 off Cedar Point. Stripers (Bass, Striped) can also be found in the area on bucktails. Mattituck Inlet has some decent Fluke however the farther you go West, the better the bite. Porgy are off the motel and the firing range.






Jamesport Bait & Tackle
631-298-5450

June 15, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Fluke [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] is better in the bay but they are hitting out of the inlet as well. The ocean might be a great bet for the weekend. There is plenty of Bluefish in the bay. Stripers (Bass, Striped) are swimming the inlet and are taking clams drifted with Clam Chum. They are also hot by Gardiners. They are taking bucktails with a heavy sinker and long leader. Anglers are drifting and doing very well.

OFFSHORE – Shark (Shark, Shortfin Mako) is picking up offshore this week. We are seeing some good sizes coming in. Tuna (Tuna, Bluefin) are way out at the Canyon and have not moved in.

BAIT REPORT – Blue Crabs seem to be making a comeback this year. Bunker (Menhaden) and Spearing are swimming the inside.


Dick’s Bait & Tackle
631-281-9070

June 9, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – There are quite a bit of fish around. If you are heading out you’ll have your choice of just about anything. Plenty of Bass (Bass, Striped) and Bluefish can be found. There are not many Bass on the beach however the backwaters and inlets are holding great numbers. Bluefish are thick in the inlet and behind the inlet in Chinecock. Bunker are swimming this area as well as the Peconics. Fluking [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] has been picking up. Porgy (Scup) has been decent out by Gardiners. We expect these conditions to continue into the weekend.

OFFSHORE – Going offshore has not been super productive. Threshers (Shark, Thresher) are coming out of Shinnecock. Some anglers are heading to South Jersey. We have not seen any Tuna (Tuna, Blackfin) at the Canyon just yet however there seems to be quite a bit of bait holding up so we expect to see some fish move in soon.

BAIT REPORT – Bunker (Menhaden) are swimming the inlets and back in the Peconics this week. There are some Sandeels and Spearing around but they are slim compared to the Bunker.


White Water Outfitters
631-594-3336
https://whitewateroutfitters.net

June 1, 2016

Shelter Island

INSHORE – The beach hasn’t been producing as well as the inside. Anglers fishing inside are finding lots of Bluefish and Stripers (Bass, Striped). The fish are on the big pods of Bunker so anything that is either a Bunker or looks like one is going to be a good thing to throw at them.

OFFSHORE – We are starting to get a little bit of Bluefin (Tuna, Bluefin) out at the canyons. There hasn’t really been a good chunk bite so make sure you stick to trolling baits and trolling lures. There are also some sharks out there but the focus has been on the Tunas.

BAIT REPORT – Inside we’re seeing quite a few pods of Bunker (Menhaden) for those hunting for bait.


White Water Outfitters
631-594-3336
https://whitewateroutfitters.net

May 24, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Fluking [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] has been great since the opening day. It was slow at first but is picking up as the water warms up. Plenty of Bluefish invaded the bay from 3-15 lbs. A few Bass (Bass, Striped) are mixed in throughout the bay. Bunker and Mackerel are working best. As far as lures, Tins and Popping Plugs are best. Blue Clawed Crabs are beginning to show up. Bluefish and Bass can be found in the inlet drifting Clams, Bucktails or Diamond jigs.






Dick’s Bait & Tackle
631-281-9070

May 20, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Bass (Bass, Striped) and Blues (Bluefish) are biting at Shinnecock. The Stripers are biting well along the moving tide. The inlets are holding fish and the back is better than the beach so far. There are mixed Fluke [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] in the area as well. In Peconic the Weakfish, Porgy and Fluke are being caught.



BAIT REPORT – There is still a fair amount of Bunker (Menhaden) in Peconic. There are also still plenty of Spearing around.


White Water Outfitters
631-594-3336
https://whitewateroutfitters.net

May 20, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Bass (Bass, Striped) and Blues (Bluefish) are biting at Shinnecock. The Stripers are biting well along the moving tide. The inlets are holding fish and the back is better than the beach so far. There are mixed Fluke [Flounder, Summer (Fluke)] in the area as well. In Peconic the Weakfish, Porgy and Fluke are being caught.



BAIT REPORT – There is still a fair amount of Bunker (Menhaden) in Peconic. There are also still plenty of Spearing around.


White Water Outfitters
631-594-3336
https://whitewateroutfitters.net

May 12, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Captain Steven Sr reports that despite Mother Nature we beat our way out to the grounds. We did not have a great start to the trip due to the conditions. Fishing was very slow. By 11AM conditions straightened out and we had good drifts with excellent fishing until about 2PM with double headers coming over the rails. The weather gave us a curveball and fishing slowed down. By about 5PM things changed and we started picking away again until we had to go home. Captain Steven Sr and mates Steve “Ho” and Steve Martinez filleted for over 3 hours sending everyone home with a great product. All in all it was a good trip with everyone taking home plenty of fish. High hook was Michael Bunch from East Hampton, NY with Tile (Tilefish, Blueline), Hake and Barrelfish. The first place pool went to Joey Montalto from Bronx, NY and second place went to Jacob Leifer from Hershey, PA. The largest edible pool went to Adam Nowak from Linden, NJ with a Barrelfish.






Viking Fleet
631-668-6668
www.vikingfleet.com

May 3, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Inshore is the main focus for anglers this week. Small Stripers (Bass, Striped) are everywhere from 15-25 inches. The bite is consistent and the fish have been easy to catch. There is a fair amount of Bluefish to the West and a few right off the beach. The back is the best place to fish as there is not much action from the beach this week.



BAIT REPORT – The bay is full of Bunker (Menhaden) this week. They are early but are thick. Check out the open house May 14-15 including sales, contests and a BBQ!


White Water Outfitters
631-594-3336
https://whitewateroutfitters.net

April 28, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Striped Bass (Bass, Striped) are catching locally. From the river use Sand or Blood worms with 2/0 or 3/0 hooks. From local beaches like South Amboy, Cliffwood Beach and Union Beach – use fresh Clams (cut them in half) or fresh Bunkers with 4/0 or 5/0 bait holder or octopus hooks. From boat search Buoy 14 and 19 in Raritan Reach Channel. Use Bunker chunks or troll Stretch 25, umbrella rigs or Rockfish Candy lure. Bluefish are everywhere in the Bay. Use Bunker chunks with steel leader hooks or metals (like Avas and Gators) or surface poppers. Flounder(Flounder, Winter) – No closed season. 2 fish bag limit anytime. Belmar and Shark River. Use pieces of sand or blood worms and Clam. Blackfish (Tautog) – Shrewsbury Rocks, Scotland lights, 17 Fathom and Rattlesnake. Use Clams or Green Crabs. Season ends on 4/30.






Fred’s Bait and Tackle
732-721-4747
www.fredsbaitnj.com

April 20, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Stripers (Bass, Striped) are open now and holding up in the creeks. Small baits are the best method to catch them. The sizes are small to near keeper so far and there may be a few keepers but you’ll have to search through a lot of fish to find them. There have been no reports of them outside the creeks just yet.

OFFSHORE – Anglers continue to fish Cod (Cod, Atlantic) in the deeper structures.

BAIT REPORT – Adult sized Bunker (Menhaden) are running the creeks this week. We are also seeing some Spearing in the area.


White Water Outfitters
631-594-3336
https://whitewateroutfitters.net/index.asp

April 13, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – There is not a whole lot of activity quite yet. The migratory fish have not moved in at this point. There are some small holdover Stripers (Bass, Striped) but most angler aren’t targeting them. Anglers are throwing bucktails and small rubbers to find the Stripers.






White Water Outfitters
631-594-3336
https://whitewateroutfitters.net/index.asp

April 7, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Fish are beginning to enter the bay this week. The temperatures have dropped a bit so things are actually slowing down. Bluefish, Stripers (Bass, Striped) and Bunker are coming in. Large sizes of Bass are being caught by the inlet on Bunker. Schoolies are being caught as well. Winter Flounder (Flounder, Winter) are also open so anglers that catch any can keep them. Worms and Clams are working best for bait. Keep in mind Striped Bass are closed until April 15th.

OFFSHORE – There have been a few Cod (Cod, Atlantic) and Ling being caught on the offshore wrecks. The bite is not hot however anglers who put their time in may find some.

BAIT REPORT – Bunker (Menhaden) have moved into the bays this week.


Dick’s Bait & Tackle
631-281-9070

April 1, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – There is not a lot of action from this area so far this week. It is still a bit early for catching Stripers (Bass, Striped). It is also the opening of Flounder (Flounder, Southern) this week however not too many anglers are heading out to search for them as of yet. Anglers getting ready for the Spring bite can always check out our Fish feature which provides lots of tips and tricks as well as our GPS Hotspots which will keep your lines tight!






White Water Outfitters
631-594-3336
https://whitewateroutfitters.net/index.asp

March 21, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – There is more fishing happening this week and anglers are excited that Spring patterns are beginning to set in. We are beginning to see some small Stripers (Bass, Striped) turn up in the harbor. They are following the Bunker run that is beginning to show up. We expect to see sizes increase in the next few weeks when things heat up.



BAIT REPORT – Bunker (Menhaden) are moving in the shallows this week. They can be found throughout the harbor.


Cow Harbor Bait & Tackle
631-239-1631

March 18, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

OFFSHORE – Things have been slow in this area as of late. There are still Cod, Atlantic farther out on the local wrecks. They are in roughly 120 ft of water along with some Pollock, Atlantic. The mid range wrecks are producing the best. This has been the main focus of most anglers as the Striper (Bass, Striped) bite has not heated up. There is quite a bit of action in the freshwater so there is a lot of focus in this area as well.

BAIT REPORT – Toward the West there are some Herring in the deeper canals this week.


Dick’s Bait & Tackle
631-281-9071

March 9, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Bass, Striped are being caught in the bay and are catch and release at this time. This has been the main focus right now. Pollock and Cod, Tommy, have been slow. Anglers are waiting for the Striper bite to heat up and open for anglers to target. The bite is typical of this time of year. Anglers preparing for the Spring pattern can always check out our Fish Guide with tons of helpful Tips and Tricks to keep your lines tight.



BAIT REPORT – Some small amounts of Herring have shown up this week.


Causeway B&T
516-785-3223

02/03/2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Weather has made inshore inlets and piers fairly inconsistent. Lingcod and Cod (Cod, Atlantic) can be caught while drifting inshore with clams. The Herring reports have been pretty much nonexistent.. Some areas along Long Island have seen Pollock (Pollock, Atlantic) on red, white, or pink artificials. Diamond jigs are also popular. The Pollock fishing is fairly sporadic so there isn’t really a best spot to fish. At least a bad day of fishin’ beats a good day of workin’. Be sure to check out our Fish Guide for tips on Pollock, Cod, and Lingcod for some additional angling tips!

OFFSHORE – The weather and time of year has made reports limited for this area. Most offshore anglers are heading to water up to 180ft deep while looking for Cod (Cod, Atlantic). There’s going to be some Pollock, Lingcod, and Skates (Skate, Winter) in the same areas. Lately the waters to the west of Long Island haven’t fished as well as waters to the east. Dogfish (Dogfish, Spiny) are usually caught out there too. Check out our GPS hotspots for some nonpublic numbers to try on your next outing. Spring is just around the corner and we’re looking forward to getting back on the water with you when the fishing, and hopefully the weather, heats up!




Pro Angler Team

February 16, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

OFFSHORE – As the Winter season has set in there is not much action to be found in this area. Our sources are keeping warm inside and there have been no reports submitted this week. For the anglers eagerly awaiting the Spring thaw, feel free to check out all of the great features available on Pro Angler to keep you busy! From planning next season’s hot spots on your GPS map to getting some tasty recipes for the fish you will catch, Pro Angler will keep you hooked! If you just can’t wait that long, take a look at your Southern Fellow anglers in Florida! Check out their weather, read the reports of their areas and maybe even let the warm weather lure you down for a saltwater fishing trip. Pro Angler has all your off-season cravings covered!




Pro Angler Team

February 10, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

OFFSHORE – As the Winter season has set in there is not much action to be found in this area. Our sources are keeping warm inside and there have been no reports submitted this week. For the anglers eagerly awaiting the Spring thaw, feel free to check out all of the great features available on Pro Angler to keep you busy! From planning next season’s hot spots on your GPS map to getting some tasty recipes for the fish you will catch, Pro Angler will keep you hooked! If you just can’t wait that long, take a look at your Southern Fellow anglers in Florida! Check out their weather, read the reports of their areas and maybe even let the warm weather lure you down for a saltwater fishing trip. Pro Angler has all your off-season cravings covered!




Pro Angler Team

February 4, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

OFFSHORE – As the Winter season has set in there is not much action to be found in this area. Our sources are keeping warm inside and there have been no reports submitted this week. For the anglers eagerly awaiting the Spring thaw, feel free to check out all of the great features available on Pro Angler to keep you busy! From planning next season’s hot spots on your GPS map to getting some tasty recipes for the fish you will catch, Pro Angler will keep you hooked! If you just can’t wait that long, take a look at your Southern Fellow anglers in Florida! Check out their weather, read the reports of their areas and maybe even let the warm weather lure you down for a saltwater fishing trip. Pro Angler has all your off-season cravings covered!




Pro Angler Team

January 29, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

OFFSHORE – As the Winter season has set in there is not much action to be found in this area. Our sources are keeping warm inside and there have been no reports submitted this week. For the anglers eagerly awaiting the Spring thaw, feel free to check out all of the great features available on Pro Angler to keep you busy! From planning next season’s hot spots on your GPS map to getting some tasty recipes for the fish you will catch, Pro Angler will keep you hooked! If you just can’t wait that long, take a look at your Southern Fellow anglers in Florida! Check out their weather, read the reports of their areas and maybe even let the warm weather lure you down for a saltwater fishing trip. Pro Angler has all your off-season cravings covered!




Pro Angler Team

January 22, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

OFFSHORE – As the Winter season has set in there is not much action to be found in this area. Our sources are keeping warm inside and there have been no reports submitted this week. For the anglers eagerly awaiting the Spring thaw, feel free to check out all of the great features available on Pro Angler to keep you busy! From planning next season’s hot spots on your GPS map to getting some tasty recipes for the fish you will catch, Pro Angler will keep you hooked! If you just can’t wait that long, take a look at your Southern Fellow anglers in Florida! Check out their weather, read the reports of their areas and maybe even let the warm weather lure you down for a saltwater fishing trip. Pro Angler has all your off-season cravings covered!




Pro Angler Team

January 15, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

OFFSHORE – As the Winter season has set in there is not much action to be found in this area. Our sources are keeping warm inside and there have been no reports submitted this week. For the anglers eagerly awaiting the Spring thaw, feel free to check out all of the great features available on Pro Angler to keep you busy! From planning next season’s hot spots on your GPS map to getting some tasty recipes for the fish you will catch, Pro Angler will keep you hooked! If you just can’t wait that long, take a look at your Southern Fellow anglers in Florida! Check out their weather, read the reports of their areas and maybe even let the warm weather lure you down for a saltwater fishing trip. Pro Angler has all your off-season cravings covered!




Pro Angler Team

January 6, 2016

Shelter Island Fishing Report

OFFSHORE – As the Winter season has set in there is not much action to be found in this area. Our sources are keeping warm inside and there have been no reports submitted this week. For the anglers eagerly awaiting the Spring thaw, feel free to check out all of the great features available on Pro Angler to keep you busy! From planning next season’s hot spots on your GPS map to getting some tasty recipes for the fish you will catch, Pro Angler will keep you hooked! If you just can’t wait that long, take a look at your Southern Fellow anglers in Florida! Check out their weather, read the reports of their areas and maybe even let the warm weather lure you down for a saltwater fishing trip. Pro Angler has all your off-season cravings covered!




Pro Angler Team

December 29, 2015

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – “The weather has not been ideal this week and has shut down most fishing in the area. Anglers have not been able to make it either inshore or offshore this week. The wind has been strong from every direction and most people are planning on waiting until after the holiday to hit the water. We hope to see some Bass, Striped and Tautog continue to bite at that time. There have been a few spotty reports of Cod, Tommy coming in as well. Be sure to check your regs in regards to what’s open for harvest or just catch and release. As the Winter season has set in there is not much action to be found in this area. Our sources are keeping warm inside and there have been no reports submitted this week. For the anglers eagerly awaiting the Spring thaw, feel free to check out all of the great features available on Pro Angler to keep you busy! From planning next season’s hot spots on your GPS map to getting some tasty recipes for the fish you will catch, Pro Angler will keep you hooked! If you just can’t wait that long, take a look at your Southern Fellow anglers in Florida! Check out their weather, read the reports of their areas and maybe even let the warm weather lure you down for a saltwater fishing trip. Pro Angler has all your off-season cravings covered! Lots of great fishing gear available at White Water Outfitters to meet all your fishing needs any time of year. “






White Water Outfitters
631-594-3336
https://whitewateroutfitters.net/index.asp

December 21, 2015

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – The weather has not been ideal this week and has shut down most fishing in the area. Anglers have not been able to make it either inshore or offshore this week. The wind has been strong from every direction and most people are planning on waiting until after the holiday to hit the water. We hope to see some Bass, Striped and Tautog continue to bite at that time. Be sure to check your regs in regards to what’s open for harvest or just catch and release. As the Winter season has set in there is not much action to be found in this area. Our sources are keeping warm inside and there have been no reports submitted this week. For the anglers eagerly awaiting the Spring thaw, feel free to check out all of the great features available on Pro Angler to keep you busy! From planning next season’s hot spots on your GPS map to getting some tasty recipes for the fish you will catch, Pro Angler will keep you hooked! If you just can’t wait that long, take a look at your Southern Fellow anglers in Florida! Check out their weather, read the reports of their areas and maybe even let the warm weather lure you down for a saltwater fishing trip. Pro Angler has all your off-season cravings covered! Lots of great fishing gear available at White Water Outfitters to meet all your fishing needs any time of year.






White Water Outfitters
631-594-3336
https://whitewateroutfitters.net/index.asp

December 15, 2015

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – As the Winter season has set in there is not much action to be found in this area. Our sources are keeping warm inside and there have been no reports submitted this week. For the anglers eagerly awaiting the Spring thaw, feel free to check out all of the great features available on Pro Angler to keep you busy! From planning next season’s hot spots on your GPS map to getting some tasty recipes for the fish you will catch, Pro Angler will keep you hooked! If you just can’t wait that long, take a look at your Southern Fellow anglers in Florida! Check out their weather, read the reports of their areas and maybe even let the warm weather lure you down for a saltwater fishing trip. Pro Angler has all your off-season cravings covered!






Pro Angler Team

December 9, 2015

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – As the season is coming to a close there is not a whole lot of action in the area this week. Our reports are finding most determined anglers are heading elsewhere for fish. There are no signs of Striper (Bass, Striped) as of yet this week which close December 15th. They are likely finishing up their migration out. Should anglers decide to try their luck to take advantage of the last open weekend they can always check out our Tips feature which provides additional information and suggestions to help improve the bite.



BAIT REPORT – There has been no bait reported to be running so far this week. Most anglers have been switching to artificials to hook any remaining fish.


White Water Outfitters
631-594-3336
https://whitewateroutfitters.net/index.asp

December 3, 2015

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – A few Stripers (Bass, Striped) have shown up along the point and in the sound. The bite is expected to be around a little bit longer however once the temperature drops they will more than likely begin their move out for the year.



BAIT REPORT – So far this week there have not been any bait reported to be running. Most anglers are switching to artificial or store bought live.


White Water Outfitters
631-594-3336
https://whitewateroutfitters.net/index.asp

November 26, 2015

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – There have been plenty of Blackfish (Tautog) stacking up in the end of Sound this week, along with some Sea Bass, Black. Both are swimming on the ocean side. There are also some Stripers (Bass, Striped) that can be caught along the point as well.

OFFSHORE – The weather has been rough in this area lately and this week there have been no reports of anglers heading to the offshore. The weather has become even less favorable and most fishermen are choosing to stay on the inside. If conditions lie down in time for the holidays anglers can always check out our Tips feature which provides additional information and suggestions to help improve the catch. Dick’s Bait & Tackle can also provide an up to the minute fishing report so everyone knows exactly what to expect on the water.

BAIT REPORT – There are no bait running to report at this time.


Dick’s Bait & Tackle
631-281-9070

November 18, 2015

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – The Sound has the most action this week. Sea Bass, Black are on fire in the deep water from 75-100 ft, South of the Potato Barge. Most anglers are using any type of Clam to hook them. There are also some small, short Stripers (Bass, Striped) on the beaches still leftover from the previous run. The Albacore (Bonito, Little Tunny) have moved out by now however there are still some Blackfish (Tautog) that can be caught off the points.

OFFSHORE – The weather has been rough in this area lately however this has not stopped some determined boaters from heading out. There have been reports of Tuna, Yellowfin at the canyon. They are out there and anglers are chunking for them using Butterfish or Sardines. The early morning and late day bite still remains the best. Dick’s Bait & Tackle 631-281-9070

BAIT REPORT – There are no bait running to report at this time. For alternative suggestions anglers can always check out the Pro Angler Tip feature that provides additional information to help improve the catch.


Jamesport Bait & Tackle
631-298-5450

November 10, 2015

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – The fishing around Gardiners seems to be spotty as far as keeper Bass (Bass, Striped) are concerned. 3 way rigs are still working from the boats and anglers on the various points should be able to catch a few fish with plugs or live Eels.

OFFSHORE – The canyons are producing lots of Tuna (Tuna, Yellowfin & Tuna, Albacore). There have also been reports of some Tuna, Bigeye out there as well. Anglers have been chunking using Butterfish or Sardines to hook all three species. The early morning or late evening seems to remain the best time to be head out as the action continues to be fairly scattered throughout the day.

BAIT REPORT – There are no bait running to report at this time. For alternative suggestions anglers can always check out the Pro Angler Tip feature that provides additional information to help improve the catch.


White Water Outfitters
631-594-3336
www.whitewateroutfitters.net

November 6, 2015

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – The sound has been packed with Bass, Striped, Bluefish and even some False Albacore (Bonito, Little Tunny). Anglers are using Eels, Menhaden and Butterfish as a live bait or bucktails and plugs as an artificial alternative. The Albacore are eating smaller tins though. Every point in this area seems to be hiding fish so you shouldn’t have trouble finding a spot to hook some fish.

OFFSHORE – Tuna (Tuna, Yellowfin & Tuna, Albacore) could not get any better, especially with the nice weather. They have had a great bite lately for anglers that are mostly chunking using Butterfish or Sardines. The best times to head out on the water are either morning or evening since there has not been much action throughout the day.

BAIT REPORT – Anglers are snagging and dropping Peanut and Adult Menhaden. The run is pretty thick right now.


White Water Outfitters
631-594-3336
https://whitewateroutfitters.net/index.asp

October 23, 2015

Shelter Island Fishing Report

INSHORE – Stripers here are being caught using 3-way bucktail rigs. There’s been some decent fish caught in the bay and heading towards the back side of Montauk. Any of the bridges that allow night time fishing have also been good for anglers wanting to catch some the bigger fish that don’t have access to boats.

Dick’s Bait and Tackle
631-281-9070

October 28, 2015

Shelter Island Fishing Report

BAY – The winds have wreaked havoc on the shallow waters around Gardiners Island. Reports from here have been very limited as have the opportunities for anglers to make their way to fish here.

White Water Outfitters – The sport fishing specialists.

White Water Outfitters
288 Montauk Hwy
Hampton Bays, NY
631-594-3336
www.whitewateroutfitters.net

September 25, 2015

Shelter Island Fishing Report

BAY – The False Albacore bite has been pretty good in the Gardiners Island area. Generally the good bite is down the south side of Montauk this time of year but the fish have been busting bait all over the place between Gardiners and Orient, even up into the sound.

BAIT REPORT – There’s been a lot of rain bait through here.

White Water Outfitters – The sport fishing specialists.

White Water Outfitters
288 Montauk Hwy
Hampton Bays, NY
www.whitewateroutfitters.net
631-594-3336

September 10, 2015

Shelter Island Fishing Report

BAY – Starting to see the first of the False Albacore Tuna in the Bay. There are a bunch at the inlet too. The Albacore can be found from Gardiners Island to Orient to Montauk. Big Bluefish are around at the beach and the flats. That said, the deep water Bass fishing and Bass fishing in general hasn’t been great.

BAIT REPORT – There’s a good variety of bait, Bunker, Spearing, and Rainbait, providing a variety of different sized bait and colors.

White Water Outfitters – The sport fishing specialists.
White Water Outfitters
288 Montauk Hwy
Hampton Bays, NY
631-594-3336
www.whitewateroutfitters.net

September 1, 2015

Shelter Island Fishing Report

BAY – There’s some False Albacore passing through between the bay and Gardiners Island. The fall Stripers haven’t really been pounding through yet. It’s pretty much typical summertime fishing around here.

BAIT REPORT – There’s lots of different sized baits around right now including Bunker, Spearing and Rainbait.

White Water Outfitters – The sport fishing specialists.

288 Montauk Hwy
Hampton Bays, NY
631-594-3336

August 27, 2015

Shelter Island Fishing Report

OFFSHORE – The big word is Big Eye Tuna out at the Hudson Canyons. The Yellowfin have been a little closer to shore than the Canyons, but it’s been a little spotty. Color of trolling lures and skirting hasn’t been playing a major factor in success, but you can still use your purples, blues, etc.. Ballyhoo is still working for Tuna bait.

INSHORE – There’s lots of small Bluefish around the inlets. Smaller Bass and Fluke are passing through the surf. The Bass are mostly being caught at night using small plugs and bucktails. The Fluke will take Spearing. The Snapper Blues have been great from the piers.

BAIT REPORT – Lots of Rain Bait and Anchovies around being chased by fish. Peanut Bunker is around in good numbers off the beach.

White Water Outfitters – The sport fishing specialists.
288 Montauk Hwy
Hampton Bays, NY
631-594-3336

August 19, 2015

Shelter Island Fishing Report

There are Bluefish off of the points on the falling tide. Small Bluefish have shown up back into Jessup’s Neck. Porgies have stuck around. They’ve been pretty strong all season. A simple Porgy Rig, also known as a Hi/Lo Rig, is best for Porgies and while Seasoned anglers will usually prefer rigging clam, Squid is generally easier to rig and is great for the young kids to practice rigging bait. There’s quite a few Shiners out there that people are catching for bait. Mostly the Shiners are being used for catching Snapper Blues. They’re still little and have some growing to do before the Lion’s Club Snapper Derby. There’s some monstrous Striped Bass getting closer to Montauk. The bass have been fairly elusive in the region due to recent hot weather. There’s so much bait around for them to feed on that the popper fishing has proved to be a nice break from competing with the natural bait. Find those points and transition areas with current and pop away. As soon as this heat dissipates, we should start to see better numbers of Bass.

Michael
Jack’s True Value Hardware & Marine
188 N Ferry Rd
Shelter Island Heights, NY
631-749-0114










DISCLAIMER:
Since fishing conditions change from minute to minute we try to keep our reports as updated as possible. The United States is a large country, so we try to keep our Gardiners Island Fishing Report updated once a week. If you would like to contribute to the Gardiners Island Fishing Report, feel free to email your fishing tips to trevor@proangler.us. We rely on even small contributions to inform us that fishing conditions have changed so we can update the Gardiners Island Fishing Report.

The Gardiners Island Fishing Report is brought to you by the Pro Angler team and many, many, highly skilled Captains and bait shop owners.